Arsenal vs Everton Head-to-Head

AnaGoal will take you through the Arsenal vs Everton head-to-head saga: the stats, the epic wins, the narrative arcs, and what makes this matchup endure in English football lore.

Table of Contents

Historical overview of their rivalry

Arsenal and Everton have clashed over 200 times in competitive football—including league matches, FA Cup ties, and other domestic competitions. In fact, the all-time head-to-head record shows Arsenal holding the upper hand: over 200 meetings with more than 100 wins, while Everton have claimed around 60 to 70 victories, with a substantial number of draws.

In recent decades, Arsenal has generally dominated, especially on their home turf. Their record includes some staggering scorelines and seasons where Everton struggled to respond. But Everton have had their moments too—mostly in older eras or memorable upsets.

While Arsenal often come into matches with psychological edge, Everton’s resilience, especially at Goodison Park, has produced surprises over time. The rivalry is less about animosity and more about history, prestige, and contrasting eras in English football.

All-time stats and trends

Let’s break down the numbers behind Arsenal vs Everton head-to-head:

Metric	Arsenal	Everton	Draws / Notes
Total meetings	~225	same set	—
Wins	110+	~65	Arsenal clearly ahead
Draws	~48	(shared)	moderate number
Goals scored	~350+	~250+	Arsenal superior in goals
Home vs away split	Strong win % at home	More competitive home results	Arsenal often less dominant away, but still good

Some additional patterns to note:

Biggest Arsenal wins: Arsenal have had 7-0 victories over Everton, and other multi-goal wins.
Biggest Everton wins: In the mid-20th century, Everton once beat Arsenal 6-1.
Recent meetings: In modern Premier League seasons, draws have been more common, and the margin has tightened.
Goal patterns: Many “head-to-head” games see under 3 goals, though some matches have broken that ceiling dramatically.

These stats highlight that while Arsenal dominate overall, Everton remain a threat, especially when the underdog role frees them to take risks.

Recent head-to-head matches and key moments

To understand how this rivalry has evolved, let’s dig into recent seasons:

In the 2024–25 Premier League season, Arsenal and Everton battled to draws and hard-fought wins.
In April 2025, the sides drew 1–1 at Goodison Park. Arsenal struck first through Leandro Trossard, but Everton equalized. That match captured the tension: Arsenal pressing, Everton compact and opportunistic.
In the 2023–2024 fixture, Arsenal held off Everton with narrow victories or stalemates.
Some standout recent results:
Arsenal 0–0 Everton (a display of defensive grit)
Arsenal 2–1 Everton (tight league contests)
Everton 1–0 Arsenal (rare upset)

These matches show that the gulf has narrowed—even though Arsenal still tend to have the up.

Tactical shifts in recent games

In the modern era, matches between the two teams often hinge on:

Midfield control: Arsenal’s passing game vs Everton’s compact shape
Counterattacks: Everton often absorb pressure and break
Set pieces and transitions: In tight matches, these moments prove decisive
Defensive discipline: A single lapse can turn the tide

Arsenal tend to dominate possession and try to break Everton down, while Everton will look to exploit gaps behind the defense. These dynamics make each new meeting compelling.

Memorable matches in the Arsenal–Everton rivalry

Over the decades, certain games stand out and are etched in the memory of fans:

Arsenal 7–0 Everton (2005) — One of the largest margins; Arsenal’s attack ran riot.
Everton 6–1 Arsenal (1985) — Everton’s statement result in the mid-80s.
Competitive FA Cup or domestic cup showdowns — Though less frequent, cup matches sometimes brought additional tension and upset potential.
Recent tight draws or late winners — In modern seasons, single moments (a penalty, a red card, a counter) decided matches.

These games reflect both extremes of the rivalry—blowouts and knife-edge battles.

Head-to-head importance and psychology

Why do fans care so much about Arsenal vs Everton head-to-head?

Legacy and prestige: These clubs carry storied histories, so their clashes feel like more than just three points.
Momentum in seasons: A win or loss in this fixture can shift confidence, especially for Everton trying to escape midtable, or Arsenal chasing top spots.
Player narratives: When a player scores in this matchup, it gets magnified (think of highlight reels, chants, bragging rights).
Fan identity: For Everton fans, beating Arsenal feels like punching above the weight. For Arsenal fans, maintaining dominance is a matter of pride.

In the modern era, with both clubs undergoing transitions, every meeting is a chance to reinforce identity and momentum.

What to expect going forward

Looking ahead, the Arsenal vs Everton head-to-head narrative will likely continue to evolve in interesting ways:

Squad changes: As new signings come in, especially attacking players or defenders, the balance can shift.
Coaching tactics: If Everton adopt more aggressive or high-press styles, they could surprise Arsenal more often.
Form and injuries: In tight tables, how fit or consistent each squad is will matter.
Psychological edge: Even as Arsenal’s dominance is historical, Everton might chip away at that cushion.

The rivalry might become more balanced—or see occasional surprising upsets—that make every fixture must-watch.

Conclusion

In this article, AnaGoal has accompanied you through the rich tapestry of the Arsenal vs Everton head-to-head record: from all-time stats and dominant eras to recent battles and psychological weight. While Arsenal maintain a lead in wins and goals across over 200 meetings, Everton’s moments of defiance and surprise add depth to the rivalry.

Arsenal vs Everton head-to-head remains a fixture that delivers emotion, stories, and unpredictability. If you’re following their next meeting, expect drama, tension, and quality football. Stay tuned to AnaGoal for the latest head-to-head updates, match previews, lineups, and post-match analysis.